HomeOPINIONNigerian democracy and a judiciary in the mud

Nigerian democracy and a judiciary in the mud

-

Nigerian democracy and a judiciary in the mud

By Uduma Oko Uduma

A democracy does not necessarily die when soldiers seize power, nor does it always perish when politicians manipulate elections, subvert constitutions or convert public office into private estates. Sometimes, its death begins more quietly, more insidiously and considerably more dangerously: when the institution constitutionally entrusted with defending justice becomes an object of public suspicion.

Nigeria’s judiciary, once regarded as the final sanctuary of the oppressed and the ultimate restraint upon political absolutism, is facing an alarming crisis of confidence.

- Advertisement -

The judiciary is democracy’s last firewall. But what happens when the custodians of that firewall are themselves suspected of opening its gates to the arsonists?

Nigeria has had jurists whose intellectual distinction and personal integrity remain enduring monuments to judicial excellence. Justices Chukwudifu Oputa, Kayode Eso, Niki Tobi, Akinola Aguda, Mohammed Bello, Chukwunweike Idigbe, Andrew Obaseki and Augustine Nnamani belonged to a tradition in which judicial authority was earned through scholarship, courage and fidelity to conscience.

Justice Eso’s celebrated resistance to executive lawlessness in Military Governor of Lagos State v Ojukwu remains an enduring lesson in judicial independence. Justice Oputa’s jurisprudential profundity demonstrated that the law must serve humanity, not political convenience. These distinguished men understood that the judicial robe was an obligation, not a licence for privilege. Their legacies should embarrass every occupant of the Bench who has mistaken judicial elevation for an invitation to plunder public confidence.

Consider the controversy surrounding the Supreme Court’s January 2020 Imo governorship judgment, which displaced Emeka Ihedioha and declared Hope Uzodimma governor after accepting claims concerning votes from 388 polling units. The judgment generated extraordinary public controversy, particularly concerning the evidential foundation and arithmetic underlying the decision. Whatever the finality of the pronouncement, its reverberations demonstrated how judicial decisions can profoundly unsettle public confidence in electoral justice.

- Advertisement -

The Kano Emirate controversy of May 2024 presented another institutional embarrassment. Contradictory interim orders emanating from different courts concerning the same traditional institution exposed an extraordinary failure of judicial coordination and restraint.

The Chief Justice of Nigeria consequently summoned the relevant judicial heads. Surely, courts cannot become competing political marketplaces where litigants seek whichever judicial prescription best serves their immediate interests.

More troubling, however, are allegations of financial inducement, clandestine political relationships, expensive vehicles, luxury properties, foreign accounts and hospitality exchanged for judicial favours.

There are persistent concerns about judges attending lavish political celebrations, fraternising with controversial political figures and cultivating relationships that compromise, or appear to compromise, their independence.

And what of the alleged deployment of third parties, relatives, associates, business proxies and professional intermediaries to receive benefits which judges would not dare accept directly? What of alleged cash inducements in naira and foreign currencies, concealed property acquisitions and gifts disguised as commercial transactions?

These matters demand forensic investigation. A bribe does not become respectable because it travels through another person’s account.

The question of judicial wealth deserves particularly rigorous scrutiny. Judges are public officers whose remuneration, allowances and legitimate entitlements can be established and calculated. They are not prohibited from inheriting property, investing successfully or accumulating legitimate private wealth.

Nevertheless, how does a judicial officer whose entire professional career has been spent in public service acquire an extraordinary portfolio of properties, luxury residences, investments and other assets, sometimes reportedly extending beyond Nigeria? What legitimate financial explanation accounts for such accumulation where it is manifestly disproportionate to declared earnings and independently verifiable sources of wealth?

The answer must not be conjecture. It must be a transparent examination of assets, beneficial ownership, financial declarations and unexplained wealth. The Code of Conduct for Judicial Officers expressly prohibits bribery, improper gifts, self-enrichment and the use of family members or associates to circumvent ethical restrictions. The law must be applied without sentiment.

Senior Advocates of Nigeria must equally examine their professional consciences. The silk is an honour, not an immunity from ethical scrutiny. Any legal practitioner found facilitating bribery, selling judicial access or acting as an intermediary in corrupt transactions must face the full consequences of the law. The Bar cannot preach professional sanctity while secretly providing a marketplace for judicial influence.

The National Judicial Council has demonstrated that disciplinary intervention is possible. In November 2024, it sanctioned five serving judicial officers for misconduct, including recommending compulsory retirement for two heads of court. More recently, its disciplinary proceedings have included suspensions arising from improper judicial orders. Such interventions must become more transparent, consistent and consequential.

Punishment must go beyond administrative reprimands. Proven offenders should face removal or compulsory retirement, criminal investigation and prosecution where appropriate, confiscation of illicit assets under applicable laws, recovery of public losses and disqualification from future public appointments.

The Code of Conduct Bureau, Code of Conduct Tribunal, EFCC and ICPC must discharge their respective statutory responsibilities. Asset declarations should be independently scrutinised, while unexplained acquisitions should trigger lawful investigations, including examination of beneficial ownership and third-party transactions.

But beyond institutional consequences lies a more devastating inheritance: disgrace.

What legacy does a judge bequeath to his children when his professional reputation becomes synonymous with alleged corruption, compromised judgments and questionable affluence? What surname does he leave behind for grandchildren to defend? Judicial office should confer enduring honour, not intergenerational embarrassment. No mansion, overseas property, luxury vehicle or illicit fortune is worth the permanent destruction of one’s name.

The tragedy is that judicial corruption does not merely compromise individual cases; it transmits hopelessness. It teaches citizens that integrity is futile, that influence supersedes evidence and that justice belongs to those who can afford its manipulation. This is how institutional decay becomes a national philosophy.

To those whose consciences have been seduced by political patronage and financial gratification, there remains an opportunity for repentance. Return to the discipline of your oath. Abandon questionable associations, surrender illicit acquisitions, cooperate with lawful investigations and recover whatever remains of your professional dignity.

Show some decorum. The Bench is not a banquet hall, the judicial robe is not a designer costume, and public office is certainly not an inheritance.

Nigeria does not need judges who are wealthy in possessions but impoverished in conscience. It needs judges whose greatest inheritance is an unblemished name.

For when justice is sold, democracy becomes a hostage, and the nation itself is left standing in the mud.

  • Uduma Oko Uduma,  a public opinion analyst, writes from Abuja
- Advertisment -
- Advertisment -Custom Text