The Federal High Court in Abuja on Wednesday held that former governor Gabriel Suswam is the valid candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC) for the 2027 Benue North East Senatorial District election, nullifying the emergence of Sen. Emmanuel Udende.
Justice Inyang Ekwo ruled that Suswam, the plaintiff in the case, had proven his case by the preponderance of evidence required by law.
Justice Ekwo agreed with the argument of the ex-governor that he was unlawfully substituted by the party, having won the majority of the valid votes cast in the APC primary poll held on May 18.
The judge held that Suswam’s substitution was not in sync with the provisions of the Electoral Act and the 1999 Constitution (as amended), including the APC’s Constitution.
He said that neither the incumbent Senator, Udende, nor APC could provide evidence to contradict the claims of Suswam and the report of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), which monitored the primary election.
The lawsuit emanated after Suswam was said to have been declared winner of the APC primary held on May 18 by the APC National Assembly Primary Election Committee, after polling 131, 083 votes to defeat Udende who scored 1,364 votes.
The former governor’s name was, however, alleged to have been substituted by the party with the name of the lawmaker.
Dissatisfied, Suswam filed a suit, marked: FHC/ABJ/CS/1470/2026, to challenge the alleged unlawful substitution, praying the court to recognise him as the validly elected candidate of the APC for the senatorial district.
The former governor joined the APC, Udende and INEC as defendants in the suit.
During proceedings, counsel to INEC, Anthony Malik, SAN, told the court that documents relating to the conduct of the primary indicated that Suswam won the exercise.
Malik urged the court to determine the dispute in accordance with the result of the primary election, maintaining that the electoral body had placed before the court its report on the exercise, as well as the result.
He consequently asked the court to uphold the outcome showing Suswam as the winner of the primary.
Suswam’s counsel, Jibrin Okutepa, SAN, also urged the court to grant the reliefs sought by his client.
Okutepa asked the court to reject the preliminary objections raised against the suit by the APC and Udenbe, arguing that the objections lacked merit.
However, counsel to the APC, A. G. Yirvoms, asked the court to uphold the party’s preliminary objection and dismiss Suswam’s case.
Delivering the judgment, Justice Ekwo dismissed the preliminary objections raised against the suit by the defendants, for lacking in merit.
The judge disagreed with the objections raised by the defendants challenging the jurisdiction of the court to adjudicate on the matter on the grounds of being an internal affair of the party.
Justice Ekwo held that contrary to the position of the defendants, the jurisdiction of the court was properly activated by the plaintiff based on the documentary evidence placed before the court.
He held that once an aspirant who participated in a party primary election alleges non-compliance with the provisions of the Electoral Act and the guidelines and constitution of the political party, the jurisdiction of the court can be activated to entertain his grievance.
He added that the provisions of the Electoral Act are over and above the guidelines of a political party.
“Therefore, the issue of internal affairs is of no moment,” Justice Ekwo ruled.
The judge held that the plaintiff, being an aspirant who participated in the party’s primary election for the Benue North- East senatorial seat, had the requisite locus standi to challenge the outcome of the said election.
He equally disagreed with the defendants that the plaintiff’s suit was statute-barred going by the material evidence before the court.
“By the findings of this court, the notice of preliminary objections raised by the defendants is resolved against them in favour of the plaintiff and it is hereby dismissed,” the judge held.
On the substantive matter, the judge equally resolved the issues in favour of Suswam.
He held that the 1st and 2nd defendants had failed to make a case against the plaintiff, to warrant the court to decide otherwise.
Justice Ekwo observed that, going by the documentary evidence before the court, there was no dispute that there was a primary election of the 1st defendant (APC) which was monitored by the INEC (3rd defendant).
He equally observed that neither the 1st and 2nd defendants were contesting the report of the INEC which monitored the primary election for the Benue North- East senatorial seat.
Justice Ekwo held that INEC, in the said undisputed report, maintained that the plaintiff won the APC primary held on May 18, polling 131,083 votes against the 2nd defendant (Udende) who scored 1,364 votes.
He held that neither the 1st and 2nd defendant had contradicted the report of INEC by tendering a different result other than the one tendered by the plaintiff and INEC, to prove that it was the 2nd defendant who won the primary.
“Therefore, the court has no reason not to act on the INEC’s report since its probative value has not been diminished.
“The 1st and 2nd defendants have not tendered any other result of the election which would have proved that the 2nd defendant was the winner of the primary election.”
On the issue of substituting the name of the plaintiff with that of the 2nd defendant as winner of the primary election, based on a report by an appeal committee, the judge held that the action constituted an abuse of the plaintiff’s right to fair hearing.
He observed that the report of the APC appeal committee was dated May 18, the same day the party primary election was held and there was no evidence that Suswam was allowed to be heard.
“I find that the case of the plaintiff has been corroborated by the case of the 3rd defendant (INEC),” he said.
Justice Ekwo, who said Suswam’s case was bound to succeed, granted all the reliefs sought.
The judge ordered APC to immediately transmit Suswam’s name to INEC as its validly elected candidate.
He equally ordered INEC to, forthwith, publish the ex-governor’s name as APC candidate for the 2027 Benue North East Senatorial District election.




