HomeNEWSChappal Energies Dispute: Defence lawyers walk out after Judge orders continuation of...

Chappal Energies Dispute: Defence lawyers walk out after Judge orders continuation of trial

-

Chappal Energies Dispute: Defence lawyers walk out after Judge orders continuation of trial

By Onyewuchi Ojinnaka

Lawyers representing Chappal Energies founder and managing director, Ufoma Joseph Immanuel walked out of the Special Offences Court in Ikeja on Wednesday after Justice Mojisola Dada directed that his trial continues. The defence had argued that a subsisting court order restrained the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) from proceeding with the prosecution.

When the hearing resumed, EFCC counsel Ekene Iheanacho, (SAN), told the court that the matter was listed for continuation of trial. Immanuel’s counsel, Oluseun Awonuga, (SAN), objected and drew the court’s attention to two processes the defence said it had filed and served on the prosecution. One brought the restraining order to the court’s attention, while the other challenged the competence of the prosecution.

- Advertisement -

Justice Dada said the processes were missing from the court file. Awonuga said the registrar had told him they had to be printed in colour. He told the judge he had the documents with him and showed them to her.

In a brief ruling, Justice Dada directed that the trial proceed on an accelerated basis. Awonuga reiterated that two defence applications remained pending. He said the first was dated 3 July 2026 and served on 6 July, while the second was filed on 30 October and served on 2 November.

Awonuga argued that the order relied upon in the October application barred the EFCC from continuing the charge. He objected to Iheanacho’s continued appearance in the case and asked him to respond on the record. The defence maintained that both the commission and its counsel had been served with the order.

The defence also said Immanuel had been admitted to Lagos State University Teaching Hospital (LASUTH) for almost a month under an order of the Federal High Court. A subsequent order directed that he return to LASUTH immediately to continue treatment. According to the defence, Justice Dada declined to take either the hospital admission or the subsequent order into account in her ruling.

- Advertisement -

After making his submissions, Awonuga took leave of the court and walked out with his team in protest. Justice Dada said Immanuel would have 30 days to retain another lawyer if he wished. She adjourned the case to 25 January 2027 for continuation of trial.

In an October 2026 ruling, Justice Josephine Obanor reaffirmed her order of 11 September 2025 and held that the EFCC should have challenged it by appeal if it disputed the decision. She said the Commission could not disregard a subsisting order and proceed with criminal charges as though it did not exist.

The ruling arose from a suit brought by Chappal Energies Mauritius Limited, Intermediate Investments Limited and Immanuel against the Attorney-General of the Federation, the EFCC, the Nigeria Police Force, R28 Limited, Biswal Limited and Adebisi Adebutu.

The court restrained the EFCC from taking further steps in Charge No. ID/27000C/2025, Federal Republic of Nigeria v. Ufoma Joseph Immanuel and Intermediate Investments Limited, pending the determination of the substantive suit. It also restrained the commission from relying on specified documents already tendered in the criminal proceedings.

“A subsisting order of court remains binding until it is set aside or otherwise lawfully discharged,” Justice Obanor said.

The EFCC filed the criminal charge at the Lagos State High Court, Ikeja Division, on 7 October 2025. It accused Immanuel and Intermediate Investments Limited of offences including obtaining property by pretence and forgery.

- Advertisment -
- Advertisment -Custom Text